See All: Food Preservation
“I’ve been wanting to make homemade beef jerky, but I’m a bit confused about the best method for dehydrating the meat. I have a dehydrator, but I’ve heard you can make jerky in an oven or even on a smoker. I’m just trying to figure out which option gives the best results and what I need to keep in mind so I don’t spoil the batch. Any advice on this? Thanks for your help!” Thanks, James, Calgary, Canada.
What’s The Best Method For Dehydrating Meat For Jerky?
Hey James, I totally get it—that first batch of jerky can feel a bit intimidating, but once you’ve done it once, you’ll realize it’s actually pretty simple. There are several methods for dehydrating meat for jerky, each with its pros and cons, but don’t worry—you’re in the right place to figure out which one works best for you.
We’ve all been there, puzzled over whether using a fancy dehydrator is better than popping the meat in the oven. I’ve even heard people swear by using smokers. So, let’s break it down, weigh the options, and make sure you’re confident about your next steps.
How To Prepare The Meat: The Jerky ABC’s
First things first, before we explore the methods, let’s quickly talk about prepping the meat. It’s almost as important as the dehydration process itself. Start with lean cuts of meat—beef, venison, turkey, they all work great. Fat doesn’t preserve well and can make the jerky spoil faster, so trim off as much as possible. Slice your meat into 1/4-inch strips against the grain; this gives the jerky its chewy texture. If you’ve ever cut it with the grain, well… let’s say you’ll get a workout trying to chew that!
For a bonus tip, toss your meat in the freezer for 30-45 minutes before slicing. It firms up the meat just enough to make slicing thin strips a breeze.
Marinade Magic: Flavor & Preservation All In One
Whether you’re team spicy, sweet, or savory, marinading the meat is a vital part of the jerky-making process. Not only does it soak in all that flavor, but it also helps preserve the meat. A good marinade usually has salt (which acts as a meat preserver), some acidic component (like vinegar or citrus juice), and a balance of herbs or spices personalized to your taste.
A common question is how long to marinate. James, if you’re like me and enjoy bold flavor, leave it in the fridge overnight, or at least 4–6 hours. A shortcut I’m guilty of once or twice? Just soaking it for an hour in a pinch—it’s good, but not as flavorful. However, if you’re patient and have more time, the longer the better.
The Dehydrating Process: Choosing Your Method
Okay, James, now let’s address the heart of your question: which dehydrating method is the best? Below, we’ll cover the three main options: dehydrators, ovens, and smokers.
Dehydrators: Dependable, Simple, and Efficient
If you already own a dehydrator like you said, this is probably the easiest method for making jerky. Dehydrators are specifically designed to remove moisture from food, and that’s exactly what we need here.
- Temperature Control: Most modern dehydrators let you set the temperature. For jerky, you’re aiming for that sweet spot of around 160°F (71°C) to keep bacteria at bay while still drying the meat effectively.
- Time: It typically takes around 4 to 6 hours to fully dehydrate meat, depending on thickness and moisture content. You’ll want to check the jerky every hour after the four-hour mark to see how it’s doing.
- Consistency: One of the big benefits of using a dehydrator is even airflow. The trays allow air to circulate around each strip of meat, leading to consistent drying without needing to rotate trays a ton during the process.
If you’re using a dehydrator, I recommend spacing out the strips of meat evenly and never overcrowding the trays—let that air flow! Your machine may come with specific instructions too, so always double-check them to make sure you’re working with the correct settings.
Oven: The Do-It-All Appliance
James, say for some reason your dehydrator isn’t working or you just want to try something different, your regular oven at home can absolutely make a mean batch of jerky.
- Temperature Control: Just like the dehydrator, you’ll want to set your oven to about 160°F (71°C). Many ovens don’t go that low, so if yours only drops to 170°F, don’t panic, it’ll still work. Just keep a close eye on things.
- Time: Expect it to take about anywhere from 6 to 12 hours. Unlike a dehydrator, ovens take a bit longer, because they aren’t as efficient at circulating the air.
- Setup: Instead of baking sheets, use the oven racks. Lay the meat strips directly over the racks and place a baking sheet underneath to catch any drips (trust me, you don’t want to deal with that cleanup without a drip tray down below!). Keeping the oven door cracked open just a bit will let moisture escape more easily, speeding up the drying process.
The main downside here is that most ovens don’t have fans inside, meaning the drying can be uneven unless you rotate the trays every couple hours. But if the neighborhood is out of dehydrators (hard to imagine, right?) your oven is up to the task.
Smokers: Achieve That Classic Smoky Flavor
This method is for jerky lovers who can’t resist that deep, smoky goodness. If you have a smoker and enjoy meat with a bold flavor, give this option some serious consideration. It’s not as “hands-off” as the other methods but worth it for the layered taste. If you aren’t careful, though, it can overpower the jerky. A steady, mild smoke is key here.
- Temperature & Smoke: The smoker should be set around 160°F-170°F (just like the dehydrator and oven). Most smokers have a built-in thermometer, but it’s a good idea to keep an external thermometer handy to ensure accuracy.
- How Long Does It Take?: Smoking jerky will probably take you between 6 to 10 hours, depending on how smoky you like it. Again, the thinner the slices, the quicker it will dry out.
- Flavors: With a smoker, you’ve got lots of options with wood chips—think hickory, applewood, cherry… Whatever gets your taste buds excited. The big advantage is that you’re adding an extra layer of flavor to your jerky that you just can’t achieve any other way.
Another thing to note is that you’ll still want to marinate the meat—even though the smoky flavor comes through, the marinade contributes to the overall result. I learned that the hard way when I rushed through a batch thinking the smoke would be enough on its own. Spoiler: it wasn’t!
How Do You Know When It’s Done?
Alright, James, this is probably the most common question after someone’s chosen their method—how do you know your jerky is ready?
Tugging on a piece of jerky is the simplest test. Take one strip and bend it slightly—it should be dry but flexible. If it cracks or snaps in half, you’ve probably overdone it a bit. A smile-worthy jerky will bend with cracks along the surface but won’t outright break.
Another trick I’ve found useful is the blot test. After you think the jerky is almost ready, pull it out and pat it with a paper towel. There shouldn’t be any excess moisture. Too much moisture can lead to inconsistent preservation (and as we both know, no one wants spoiled jerky).
How Long Will Your Homemade Jerky Last?
Once your jerky is done, how long can you store it? In general, homemade jerky can last 1 to 2 months in an airtight container if it’s kept in a cool, dry place. I personally seal mine in vacuum bags—the less air, the better. If you plan on keeping it longer, pop it in the freezer, where it can last for up to 6 months (though it’s usually gone well before then around here).
For more advanced preservation, some folks opt to use curing salt in their marinade, which extends shelf life even longer.
Troubleshooting Common Jerky Problems
Let’s go through a few common issues folks encounter. It happens to the best of us, so don’t get discouraged!
Too Dry
If your jerky’s too dry and crumbly, it’s likely been over-dehydrated. This often happens if the temperature was too high or it was left in too long. Next time, aim for that slight bendable texture we talked about earlier. Also, don’t forget to check the internal temperature halfway through—adjusting as needed can be a lifesaver.
Too Moist
If it’s too moist, bacterial growth could become an issue. Either it needed more time in the dehydrator, or the slices were too thick. Thicker slices take longer to dry. If you find this happens often, try using thinner cuts and spreading them out more evenly on the dehydrator racks.
Losing Flavor
If your jerky isn’t packing the flavor punch you’re after, it might be the marinating time. The longer it sits in the marinade, the more intense the flavor, so try letting it soak overnight. Also, make sure your dehydrator or oven doesn’t exceed 160°F, as higher temps can degrade the flavor molecules…fun fact!
Final Thoughts…
James, hopefully, this gives you a solid idea of which dehydrating method suits your needs. Each method has its pros and cons, but whether you’re using a dehydrator, oven, or smoker, the key is keeping an eye on temperature, time, and the condition of the meat as it dries. Thanks for sending in your question—get ready to enjoy some delicious homemade jerky!
Return To: Food Preservation
